Communities
How to start a paid community
To start a paid community, begin with 20 people who already know you, not 2,000 strangers. Write a one-sentence promise members can repeat. Choose one price to join or monthly billing, set up three to five categories and a welcome post, and show up daily for the first 30 days. A course inside gives people a reason to come back.
By The Creators Company team Updated 6 min read
Most paid communities don’t fail because the platform was wrong. They fail in week three, when the founder stops posting and the feed goes quiet. This guide on how to start a paid community is about getting past week three: who to invite first, what to promise, how to price it, how to set it up, and what to do every day for the first month.
Start with 20 people, not 2,000
A community with 2,000 members and nobody talking feels dead. A community with 20 members who post every day feels like the place to be. Start small on purpose.
Your first 20 are people who already trust you: past students, newsletter readers who reply, followers who comment every week. Invite them personally, one message each. “I’m starting a small group for people working on X. You’ve asked good questions before, and I’d like you in it.”
Starting with twenty also lets you learn cheaply. You’ll find out what they ask, when they show up and what makes them post, before you open the doors to everyone.
The promise: one sentence members can repeat
People join a community for an outcome, not for “a space to connect”. Write the promise as one sentence that a member could repeat to a friend:
- “A group for freelance illustrators getting their first three clients.”
- “Run your first marathon in 16 weeks, with people training at the same time.”
- “Home bakers who want to get sourdough right, with feedback on every loaf.”
A good promise names who it’s for and what changes for them. It also tells you what to remove: posts and features that don’t serve the promise.
One price to join or monthly billing: the trade-off
This is the biggest decision, and there’s no answer that suits everyone.
| One price to join | Monthly billing | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Lump sums when people join | Recurring, predictable |
| Your workload | Lower: no need to justify every month | Higher: members ask “is it worth this month?” |
| Member behaviour | Join for the course or goal, may drift away | Stay while it’s useful, cancel when not |
| Admin | No failed cards or cancellations | Failed payments to chase, cancellations every month |
| Best for | Communities built around a course or a fixed goal | Ongoing accountability, live calls, fresh material |
A one-time price works well when the community is attached to something finite, like a course, a challenge or a cohort. A monthly price works when you’re selling ongoing access to you and to fresh material.
You can also bundle them: sell a course once and include the community in its price, so there’s no monthly bill to cancel.
Setting up categories, rules and a welcome post
Categories
Start with three to five categories. Fewer than three and everything blurs together. More than five and the feed looks empty in every one. A good starting set:
- Introductions. Members say who they are and what they’re working on.
- Questions. Anything people are stuck on.
- Wins. Progress, finished work, results.
- Announcements. Only you post here. Live calls, new lessons, changes.
Add a fifth for your topic, like “Critique” for a design group or “Training logs” for runners.
Rules
Five rules at most, written in plain language, pinned at the top:
- Be kind about work in progress.
- No selling or self-promotion outside the Wins category.
- Search before you ask.
- Keep private things private: what’s shared here stays here.
- Report anything that breaks these, and I’ll handle it.
The welcome post
Pin a welcome post that tells new members exactly what to do in the first ten minutes: introduce yourself in Introductions, answer one question, and open the first lesson if there’s a course. A member who has posted once has a reason to come back: they want to see the replies.
Points and levels: do they keep people around?
Points for likes, levels and a leaderboard are common in community software now. They help in two cases: when you want to reward the members who answer other people’s questions, and when you want to unlock something (a bonus lesson, a monthly call) at a certain level.
They don’t fix a community with no reason to visit. And they can backfire: if the leaderboard rewards volume, you get low-effort posts chasing points. Use them as a thank-you to helpful members, not as the main attraction.
Adding a classroom so the course and the talk live together
Communities with a course inside them keep people longer. Members come for a lesson, see a question in the feed, answer it, and stay. The course gives structure; the feed gives the reason to come back.
Three ways to set up access:
- Open to every member. Everyone who joins gets the course. Simplest.
- Unlocked at a level. Members earn access by taking part. Good for a bonus course.
- Sold separately. The community is the entry point, and the advanced course is an extra purchase.
If you’re building the course itself, our guide on how to sell an online course covers the steps, and how to price an online course covers the price.
The first 30 days
The first month sets the habits. Plan it before you open.
Days 1 to 7. Post every day. Welcome each new member by name. Ask one easy question a day (“what are you working on this week?”). Reply to every post within a few hours.
Days 8 to 14. Start a weekly rhythm: a Monday goals thread and a Friday wins thread. Hold one live call or post one video answering the most common questions.
Days 15 to 21. Find the two or three members who answer other people’s questions. Thank them in public. Ask one of them to host a thread.
Days 22 to 30. Ask members what they’d change. Remove a category nobody uses. Write down the questions that came up most; they’re your next lessons.
After 30 days, step back a little. A healthy community is one where members talk to each other, not only to you.
Sofie, Level 3
Week 6 of the plan: ran 14 km on Sunday without stopping. Two months ago I couldn't do 5.
12 likes · 4 replies
Marco, Level 1
Hi all, I'm Marco from Milan. First marathon in April. Nervous about the long runs.
8 likes · 6 replies
Where The Creators Company fits
Communities are part of the Growth plan. A community is sold like any product in your shop: free, pay once to join, or request to join with your approval. Members post in categories you set (you choose who can post in each), reply in threads and like posts. They earn points from likes, climb levels and show up on a leaderboard. You can pin and lock posts, mute or ban members, hide posts and resolve reports, and members get a daily or weekly email digest of new posts.
The classroom sits inside the community. Attach your courses, and each one can be open to every member, unlocked at a level, or sold separately. You can run more than one community from the same shop. There’s a shorter overview of selling paid community access too.
Members pay once to join. If you need monthly billing, Skool or Circle does that; our Skool vs Circle page compares the two. Posts are text only: no images, video, polls or events in the feed.
A checklist before you open
- Write the one-sentence promise.
- List the first 20 people you’ll invite personally.
- Decide: one price to join, or monthly.
- Create three to five categories and the rules.
- Write and pin the welcome post.
- Plan the first 30 days of posts on a calendar.
- Send the invitations.
Questions people ask
How many members do I need to start a paid community?
Twenty active members is enough to make a community feel alive. What matters more than the number: they share one goal, and some of them post without being asked.
Should I charge monthly or once?
Monthly suits communities where the value keeps coming: accountability, fresh posts, live calls. One price to join suits communities built around a course or a fixed goal. Monthly brings recurring income, but also cancellations and failed cards to chase.
How much should I charge for a paid community?
It depends on the result and on what's included. Communities with a course inside or regular access to you can charge more than a discussion group. Start by pricing the course or the result, then decide whether the community is the product or the bonus.
Can I charge monthly for a community on The Creators Company?
No. A community is free or paid once, and you choose whether people join straight away or after you approve them. If you need monthly billing, Skool or Circle supports it.
What's the difference between a community and a Facebook group?
A Facebook group is free to run, but it sits inside Facebook, is hard to charge for, and competes with everything else in your members' feeds. A paid community lives on your own site, takes payment, and keeps the course and the conversation in one place.